Menu


Reviewer Guidelines

Reviewers help the editor judge whether a manuscript reports useful and well-documented community service work, and help authors improve it.

Before accepting. Accept only if the manuscript falls within your experience, you can submit the report within three weeks, and you have no conflict of interest. Tell the editor if you recognise the authors, the partner, or the programme, or if you need more time.

What to assess.

  • Whether the problem is supported by evidence from the partner, such as a needs assessment or baseline data.
  • Whether the method is described clearly enough for others to repeat it, including how partners took part in planning and implementation.
  • Whether the results are supported by evidence (for example pre-test and post-test results, indicators, products, or adoption by the partner), and whether claims of impact go beyond what the evidence shows.
  • Whether the discussion relates the results to the literature and to earlier programmes, and states the limitations.
  • Whether the programme can be sustained after it ends and whether the article explains how.
  • Whether consent, the protection of participants, and the use of photographs meet the journal’s ethics policy.
  • The clarity of the writing, figures, and tables, and the accuracy of the references.

Writing the report. Open with a short summary of the manuscript and your overall assessment. Separate major concerns from minor ones, and make each comment specific enough for the authors to act on. Keep the tone professional. Use the confidential comments field for remarks meant only for the editor, and do not contact the authors directly.

Confidentiality. Treat the manuscript as confidential. Do not share it, discuss it with others, or use it in your own work. Do not upload the manuscript or any part of it into generative AI tools.

Recommendation. Choose accept, minor revision, major revision, or reject in the review form. The editor considers all reports and makes the final decision.