Reviewer Guidelines
Manuscripts submitted to Adicita: Jurnal Hukum dan Keadilan Indonesia are evaluated through double-blind peer review. Reviewers provide objective and critical assessments to help the editor decide whether a manuscript is suitable for publication.
Before accepting. Confirm that the manuscript falls within your area of expertise, that you can complete the review within two weeks, and that you have no conflict of interest. If the manuscript does not match your specialisation, or if you are unsure about a conflict, inform the editorial office. If you need more time, contact the Editorial Secretary.
What to assess. The clarity of the title and abstract; the adequacy of the introduction, objectives, and legal or theoretical framework; the originality and contribution of the work and its fit with the scope; the soundness of the method, sources, and analysis, including the correct use of legislation, case law, and secondary literature; whether the conclusions follow from the analysis; the quality of writing and of tables and figures; and the accuracy and currency of the references (APA 7th edition).
Writing the report. Give specific and constructive comments, separate major issues from minor ones, and keep the tone professional. Use the confidential comments field for remarks meant only for the editor. Do not contact the authors directly.
Confidentiality. Treat the manuscript as confidential. Do not share it, discuss it with others, or use its content for your own work. Do not upload the manuscript or any part of it into generative AI tools. Record your assessment in the review form; your identity is disclosed only to the editor and not to the author.
Recommendation. Complete the review form and choose accepted, accepted with minor revisions, accepted with major revisions, or rejected. The editor considers all reports and makes the final decision.
