Menu


Reviewer Guidelines

Reviewers help the editor judge whether a manuscript makes a sound and useful contribution to economics, and help authors improve their work.

Before accepting. Accept only if the manuscript falls within your expertise, you can submit the report within three weeks, and you have no conflict of interest. Tell the editor if you recognise the authors or have worked with them, if you are at the same institution, or if you need more time.

What to assess.

  • The research question and its contribution compared with the existing literature.
  • The fit of the data and method with the question, including the identification strategy, the treatment of endogeneity and other sources of bias, and robustness checks.
  • The quality and source of the data, and whether the data availability statement is adequate.
  • Whether the results are reported correctly (standard errors, sample size, units) and interpreted with care, including the difference between statistical and economic significance.
  • Whether the conclusions and policy implications follow from the evidence.
  • The clarity of the writing, tables, and figures, and the accuracy and currency of the references.

Writing the report. Open with a short summary of the manuscript and your overall assessment. Separate major concerns from minor ones, and make each comment specific enough for the authors to act on. Keep the tone professional. Use the confidential comments field for remarks meant only for the editor, and do not contact the authors directly.

Confidentiality. Treat the manuscript and any data or code as confidential. Do not share them, discuss them with others, or use them in your own work. Do not upload the manuscript or any part of it into generative AI tools.

Recommendation. Choose accept, minor revision, major revision, or reject in the review form. The editor considers all reports and makes the final decision.