Peer Review Process
All manuscripts submitted to Karsa: Jurnal Dinamika Masyarakat go through a systematic selection and evaluation carried out by the Editorial Board. The journal applies double-blind peer review, in which the identities of authors and reviewers are not disclosed to one another.
- Desk review. The editorial team screens each submission for compliance with the writing guidelines, fit with the scope, and academic quality. Authors may be asked to revise before review, and the Editorial Board may reject a manuscript that is clearly unsuitable without external review.
- Peer review. A manuscript that passes the desk review is sent to at least two independent reviewers with expertise in the subject. Peer review is expected to be completed within about three weeks.
- Reviewer recommendation. Each reviewer recommends one of the following: accepted; accepted with minor revisions; accepted with major revisions; or rejected. These recommendations inform the Editorial Board's decision.
- Revision. For major revisions the author is given three weeks, and for minor revisions one week. The author submits a point-by-point response and the completed review summary form.
- Final editorial decision. The Editorial Board re-evaluates the revised manuscript. A manuscript may still be rejected if the revisions are insufficient.
- Proofreading. Accepted manuscripts are proofread for clarity, coherence, and language quality.
- Publication confirmation. The final layout is sent to the author for confirmation. The author may correct typographical errors but may not make substantive changes. Once approved, the manuscript is processed for publication on the journal's website.
