Peer Review Process
OPTIMA: Indonesian Journal of Contemporary Management uses double-blind peer review: authors and reviewers do not know each other’s identities. Only the handling editor knows who reviewed a manuscript.
- Desk review. The editorial team checks each submission for fit with the scope, compliance with the Author Guidelines, a clear research objective, a contribution to the field, and similarity with published sources. A manuscript that falls short may be returned for revision or declined without external review. The journal aims to give this decision within one week.
- Peer review. A manuscript that passes the desk review goes to at least two independent reviewers with expertise in the topic. Reviewers are asked to submit their reports within three weeks.
- Reviewer recommendation. Each reviewer recommends one of four outcomes: accepted; accepted with minor revisions; accepted with major revisions; or rejected. These recommendations inform the editor’s decision.
- Revision. Authors have three weeks for a major revision and one week for a minor revision. They return the revised manuscript with a point-by-point response and the review summary form.
- Final editorial decision. The editor re-evaluates the revised manuscript, and may send it back to the reviewers. A manuscript may still be rejected if the revision does not address the main concerns.
- Proofreading. Accepted manuscripts are proofread for clarity, coherence, and language.
- Publication confirmation. The final layout is sent to the author for confirmation. The author may correct typographical errors but may not make substantive changes. The article is then published in the next available issue.
The journal aims to give a first decision within about six weeks of submission. This is a target, not a guarantee. It replaces the conflicting timelines on the live site (two weeks in the Author Guidelines and Reviewer Guidelines, three weeks in the Review Process). Authors may appeal a decision by writing to the editor with specific reasons; an editor without a conflict of interest reviews the appeal and the result is final.
