Menu


Reviewer Guidelines

Reviewers help the editor judge whether a manuscript makes a sound and useful contribution to management research, and help authors improve their work.

Before accepting. Accept only if the manuscript falls within your expertise, you can submit the report within three weeks, and you have no conflict of interest. Tell the editor if the manuscript is outside your field, if you recognise the authors or their institution, or if you need more time. Report any sign of plagiarism or other ethical problems immediately.

What to assess.

  • Title and abstract: do they reflect the content accurately?
  • Introduction: are the background, research gap, and objectives clear, and is the relevant literature used?
  • Contribution: is the work original, and does it add to management theory or practice?
  • Theory and hypotheses: is the framework appropriate and are the hypotheses justified?
  • Method: are the sample, measures, and analysis appropriate and described clearly enough to repeat? Are reliability and validity reported where relevant?
  • Results and discussion: are the results presented clearly and interpreted with care, and does the discussion relate them to earlier studies?
  • Conclusion: does it follow from the results, and are the managerial implications and limitations stated?
  • Tables, figures, and references: are they clear, correctly sourced, and in APA style, with most references from recent journal articles?
  • Writing: is the manuscript clear and suitable for academic publication?

Writing the report. Open with a short summary of the manuscript and your overall assessment. Separate major concerns from minor ones, and make each comment specific enough for the authors to act on. Use the confidential comments field for remarks meant only for the editor, and do not contact the authors directly.

Confidentiality. Treat the manuscript as confidential. Do not share it, discuss it with others, or use it in your own work. Do not upload the manuscript or any part of it into generative AI tools. Your identity is recorded in the review form for the editor only and is not shown to the authors.

Recommendation. Choose accepted, accepted with minor revisions, accepted with major revisions, or rejected in the review form. The editor considers all reports and makes the final decision.