Sustaina: Indonesian Journal of Accounting

Menu


Peer Review Process

Sustaina: Indonesian Journal of Accounting uses double-blind peer review: reviewers do not know the authors’ identities, and authors do not know the reviewers’ identities.

  1. Desk review. The editorial team screens each submission for fit with the Focus and Scope, compliance with the Author Guidelines, completeness of declarations, and similarity with published sources (see Screening for Plagiarism). A manuscript is returned or rejected without external review if it falls outside the scope, lacks clear objectives, does not contribute to the field, or does not follow the guidelines.
  2. Peer review. Manuscripts that pass the desk review are sent to at least two independent reviewers with expertise in the topic. Reviewers may not belong to the same institution as any author, may not have co-authored with any author in the last three years, and must declare any other conflict of interest. Peer review is expected to be completed within about three weeks.
  3. Recommendation. Each reviewer recommends one of: accept; accept with minor revisions; accept with major revisions; or reject. Reviews are confidential, and reviewers may not share or use the manuscript for any other purpose.
  4. Revision. For major revisions, authors have three weeks to revise and resubmit; for minor revisions, one week. Authors submit a point-by-point response and the completed review summary form. Major revisions are normally returned to the original reviewers.
  5. Final decision. The section editor considers the reports and recommends a decision; the Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision. When reviewers disagree substantially, the editor may invite an additional reviewer. A manuscript may still be rejected if the revisions are insufficient.
  6. Proofreading and confirmation. Accepted manuscripts are copyedited and proofread. The final layout is sent to the authors for confirmation; only typographical corrections are allowed at this stage. Once approved, the article is published online and receives a DOI.
  7. Editors as authors. When an editor or board member submits a manuscript, that person is excluded from every stage of its handling, and another editor manages the review and makes the decision.
  8. Appeals. Authors may appeal a rejection once, by e-mail to Sustainajournal@gmail.com, explaining why the decision should be reconsidered. The Editor-in-Chief, or a board member with no prior involvement, reviews the appeal, and the decision on appeal is final.