Reviewer Guidelines
Thank you for reviewing for Sustaina: Indonesian Journal of Accounting.
Before accepting. Accept only if the manuscript is within your expertise, you can complete the review by the due date (about two weeks), and you have no conflict of interest. If you recognise the authors or are unsure about a conflict, tell the editor.
Confidentiality. Treat the manuscript as confidential. Do not share it, discuss it with others, or use its content for your own work. Do not upload the manuscript or any part of it into generative AI tools.
What to assess
- Does the title reflect the content, and is the abstract concise and accurate?
- Does the introduction give sufficient background, objectives, and relevant literature?
- Originality and contribution to accounting knowledge or practice, and fit with the journal’s scope.
- Theoretical grounding and the literature review.
- Appropriateness and rigour of the research design, data, and analysis, described clearly enough to be replicated.
- Whether the conclusions follow from the results and are free of unnecessary repetition.
- Clarity of writing, structure, and the presentation and sourcing of tables and figures.
- Whether references follow APA 7 and at least 80% are recent journal articles (last five years).
Writing the report. Give specific, constructive comments. Separate major issues from minor ones, keep the tone professional, and avoid comments that could identify you. Use the confidential comments field for remarks meant only for the editor.
Recommendation. Complete the Review Form and choose: accept; accept with minor revisions; accept with major revisions; or reject. The editor considers all reports and makes the final decision.
Ethical concerns. If you suspect plagiarism, data fabrication, duplicate publication, or another ethical problem, tell the editor in the confidential comments and do not contact the authors.